Rosh Hashanah Evening 5777: Tevye’s Other Hand

A new Rabbi comes to the synagogue and leads Shabbat services for the first time. Everything is going well. But just before the Sh’ma, half of the congregation stands up while the other half remains seated.

During the Oneg following the service, the rabbi asks some congregants about this interesting happenstance. The congregation is split. Each half argues vehemently – some for standing – and some for sitting.